Debate on GA-3 from 03/17/02-04/14/02
IMPORTANT NOTE
-- DO NOT post replies to any messages listed here, they won't show up in the Committee. Any discussion needing to be continued should be re-posted in the
Caucus area
.
Thank you to the supporters of GA3
-
Brian Eistep, Del. of the Republic of the Marshall Islands
4/13/02
(0)
Closing Statement on GA3
-
Yancey Westerfield/Lesotho
4/12/02
(0)
Closing Statement
-
Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China
4/12/02
(0)
For
-
B.Martin/Federated States of Micronesia
4/11/02
(0)
Statement on GA3
-
Shane Gayle..........Federal Republic of Germany
4/11/02
(1)
Welcome to you and the other 39 new delegates
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/11/02
(1)
Reply Statement
-
Shane Gayle.........Germany
4/12/02
(1)
clarrifying accepting and respecting
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/13/02
(0)
For
-
Peter E. Tasciotti/Republic of Vanuatu
4/11/02
(0)
GA3 (Cooperation between the United Nations and the Taipei Economic and Cultural Office) FAILS [14-32-8]
-
President of the General Assembly
4/11/02
(0)
ABSTAIN
-
Carolina/Greece
4/10/02
(0)
quick question
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/07/02
(1)
Re: quick question
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
4/08/02
(0)
Against
-
Zeek Earl / South Africa
4/04/02
(1)
sorry
-
zeek earl / south africa
4/05/02
(1)
*All Delegates Please Read*
-
President of the General Assembly
4/06/02
(0)
GA3 (Cooperation between the United Nations and the Taipei Economic and Cultural Office) - VOTE HERE
-
President of the General Assembly
4/03/02
(1)
VOTING CLOSED
-
President of the General Assembly
4/11/02
(0)
Re: GA3 (Cooperation between the United Nations and the Taipei Economic and Cultural Office) - VOTE HERE
-
Carolina/Greece
4/10/02
(1)
ABSTAIN
-
Carolina/Greece
4/10/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Craig Countryman/Bangladesh
4/10/02
(0)
Against
-
Siir Kilkis/Turkey
4/10/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Augustine Goh, Delegate of Federal Republic of Yugoslavia
4/10/02
(0)
Against
-
Sean Beck/Dominican Republic
4/09/02
(0)
Abstain
-
Jai Patel/Republic of Zimbabwe
4/07/02
(0)
against
-
Nathan Bishop/ Pakistan
4/07/02
(0)
Against
-
Beth Borzone/Uganda
4/07/02
(0)
For
-
Colin Babin / Jamaica
4/07/02
(0)
Abstain
-
Alison Fenney/Cape Verde
4/07/02
(0)
Against
-
Tyler Bender/Austria
4/07/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Czech Republic
4/07/02
(1)
Point of order
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/09/02
(1)
Confirmed (n/t)
-
President of the General Assembly
4/11/02
(0)
AGAINST (n/t)
-
Mike Arthus/Costa Rica
4/07/02
(0)
abstain
-
Steven Wagner/Israel
4/06/02
(0)
For
-
Jesse Ochoa/New Zealand
4/06/02
(0)
Against
-
Ben Laughlin/Haiti
4/06/02
(0)
Against
-
Matthew Roberson/North Korea
4/06/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Katie Manhart/Nepal
4/06/02
(0)
Against
-
Zeek Earl / South Africa
4/06/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Ryan Mulvey / Republic of Moldova
4/06/02
(0)
For
-
Ari Freilich/Chile
4/06/02
(0)
ABSTAIN
-
Lewis Atkinson / Argentina
4/06/02
(0)
Against
-
Fakhruddin Gulamabbas/Malaysia
4/06/02
(0)
Against
-
Doug McCloud/Belarus
4/05/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Magdalena Igartua/Latvia
4/05/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Nicolae Ivanov/Republic of Kazakstan
4/05/02
(1)
Point of order
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/06/02
(1)
Confirmed & Note
-
President of the General Assembly
4/08/02
(0)
For
-
Jima Walsh
4/05/02
(1)
Point of Order
-
Vlad Gil (Russian Federation)
4/05/02
(1)
Confirmed (n/t)
-
President of the General Assembly
4/06/02
(0)
Observer Present (+ Statement against GA3)
-
Martin Köhring / European Union
4/05/02
(0)
For
-
Melissa Cubillas/Denmark Delegation
4/05/02
(0)
For
-
Mikael Katz-Lavigne / Seychelles
4/05/02
(0)
Observer Present
-
Drew Beck/Caribbean Community
4/05/02
(0)
Against
-
Drew Beck/Barbados
4/05/02
(0)
For
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
4/05/02
(0)
abstain
-
Brian Grassie/USA
4/05/02
(0)
Observer Present
-
Ken Arnold / Commonwealth Secretariat
4/05/02
(0)
For
-
Taylor Green/Iceland
4/04/02
(0)
AGAINST (N/T)
-
Martin Galanternik/Iraq
4/04/02
(0)
Against and brief comment
-
Matt Madej/Poland
4/04/02
(0)
FOR
-
Ian Sutton/Republic of Korea
4/04/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Sumeer Kalyani / India
4/04/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Sumeer Kalyani / India
4/04/02
(1)
POINT OF ORDER (VOTE COUNTED TWICE)
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
4/04/02
(1)
Confirmed (n/t)
-
President of the General Assembly
4/06/02
(0)
Against
-
Robert Lane / Republic of France
4/04/02
(0)
Abstain
-
Ian Kowalski / Mauritius
4/04/02
(0)
Against(n/t)
-
Marcel Carrijo/Brazil
4/04/02
(0)
Against (n/t)
-
Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China
4/04/02
(0)
Against
-
Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico
4/04/02
(0)
No
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
4/04/02
(1)
POINT OF ORDER (Should be FOR, AGAINST or ABSTAIN)
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
4/05/02
(1)
Response
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
4/05/02
(1)
Point of Order Denied & Reminder to UK
-
President of the General Assembly
4/06/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic
4/04/02
(0)
against
-
Kim Constable - Italy
4/04/02
(0)
For
-
David Ramli/Commonwealth of Australia
4/04/02
(0)
FOR
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
4/04/02
(0)
For + Statement
-
Yancey Westerfield/Lesotho
4/03/02
(1)
Apologies--Above should be "Against"
-
Yancey Westerfield
4/04/02
(1)
Confirmed (n/t)
-
President of the General Assembly
4/04/02
(0)
For
-
Joaquin Patron / Liechtenstein
4/03/02
(0)
Against
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
4/03/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Vlad Gil (Russian Federation)
4/03/02
(0)
Against
-
Jonathon Potter / Republic of Guinea
4/03/02
(0)
Observer present
-
Brian Eistep/Asian-African Legal Consultative Committee
4/03/02
(1)
Abstain (n/t)
-
Dan Frøskeland / Japan
4/04/02
(0)
For
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/03/02
(0)
AGAINST
-
Aaron Connelly / España
4/03/02
(0)
For
-
Tom Melville/Peru
4/03/02
(0)
For.
-
Stephen Roberts/Libyan Socialist Jaramariha
4/03/02
(0)
FOR, or AGAINST, or ABSTAIN
-
Name / Country
4/03/02
(1)
For
-
Taylor Green/Iceland
4/04/02
(1)
Disregard the last vote, I will re-vote properly, my apologies
-
Taylor Green/Iceland
4/04/02
(1)
Confirmed (n/t)
-
President of the General Assembly
4/06/02
(0)
Summary of Points
-
Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China
4/03/02
(1)
Re: Summary of Points (typos corrected)
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/03/02
(0)
Re: Summary of Points
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/03/02
(0)
Lesotho's 2 Points against GA3
-
Yancey Westerfield/Lesotho
4/02/02
(1)
Agreement with RMI
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
4/03/02
(0)
response
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/03/02
(0)
RMI's 13 points regarding GA3
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/02/02
(1)
examples
-
Brian Eistep/Asian-African Legal Consultative Committee
4/03/02
(1)
above as Marshall Islands - not AALCC
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/03/02
(0)
Clean up
-
UNOL Staff
3/30/02
(0)
Condolences to Great Britain
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
3/30/02
(1)
Great Loss
-
Taylor Green/Iceland
4/02/02
(0)
Thank you to the Irish, Brazilian, and Liechtensteiner delegations
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/31/02
(0)
Condolences
-
Marcel Carrijo / Brazil
3/31/02
(0)
Condolences to Great Britain
-
Joaquin Patron / Liechtenstein
3/30/02
(0)
Condolences to Great Britain
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
3/30/02
(0)
We have come to a decision in regards to GA3
-
Peter Tasciotti, Vanuatu
3/29/02
(0)
CALM DOWN!
-
Mike Arthus/Costa Rica
3/29/02
(1)
Re: CALM DOWN!
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/30/02
(0)
Call for Peaceful Talks between Delegates
-
Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico
3/29/02
(0)
Remarks - General
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/29/02
(0)
Russian Position
-
Vlad Gil (Russian Federation)
3/29/02
(0)
Comments on GA3, threats and Second to Russia´s Motion
-
Marcel Carrijo / Brazil
3/29/02
(1)
Just to add
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/30/02
(1)
Just to add
-
Marcel Carrijo / Brazil
3/30/02
(0)
Motion and Rule 83
-
President of the General Assembly
3/29/02
(1)
POINT OF ORDER
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/29/02
(1)
Point of Order Accepted *Delegates Please Read!*
-
President of the General Assembly
3/29/02
(0)
Motion and Statement
-
Vlad Gil (Russian Federation)
3/27/02
(1)
On Important Questions and a Point of Order
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/28/02
(1)
Not true
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/29/02
(1)
Re: Not true
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/29/02
(1)
3 points
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/29/02
(1)
Re: 3 points
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/29/02
(1)
let me try again - concerning what occurred -
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/30/02
(1)
Ruling Already Reached
-
President of the General Assembly
3/31/02
(0)
last line retracted
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/29/02
(0)
Syria agrees with Russia
-
Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic
3/28/02
(1)
rebuttal of statements
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
4/07/02
(0)
unprecedented
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/27/02
(1)
On the Debate on GA-3
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/27/02
(1)
nicely phrased
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/28/02
(0)
Concurrence (n/t)
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
3/28/02
(0)
Re: On the Debate on GA-3
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/27/02
(1)
Re: On the Debate on GA-3
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/28/02
(1)
Re: On the Debate on GA-3
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/29/02
(0)
Our Stand
-
David Ramli/Commonwealth of Australia
3/27/02
(0)
Stand on GA3
-
Mike Arthus/Costa Rica
3/26/02
(1)
Condolances
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
3/27/02
(0)
Leave of Absense and a comment re: GA3
-
Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria
3/26/02
(0)
Syria will not involve itself anymore in GA3 debates
-
Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic
3/26/02
(1)
And all along I thought it was threats
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/28/02
(0)
Debating with rage?
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
3/26/02
(0)
E-mail Situation
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
3/25/02
(1)
Re: E-mail Situation - see you later and another point
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/25/02
(0)
GA 3 will bring political turmoil to Far East. Syria ask for a vote against it
-
Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic
3/25/02
(1)
Now, I suppose it is Syria's turn . . . .
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/25/02
(1)
Re: Now, I suppose it is Syria's turn . . . .
-
UNOL staff
3/26/02
(0)
Brief statement (disappointment)
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
3/25/02
(1)
Real quick
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/25/02
(1)
Re: Real quick
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
3/26/02
(0)
Regarding "The Peoples Paper"
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/24/02
(0)
Formal Support Of GA3 (appology To PRC)
-
Stephen Roberts/Libyan Socialist Jaramariha
3/24/02
(1)
Re: Formal Support Of GA3 (appology To PRC)
-
Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic
3/25/02
(1)
Point of Order
-
Tom Melville/peru
3/26/02
(1)
Re: Point of Order
-
Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic
3/26/02
(1)
Point of Order Out of Order
-
President of the General Assembly
4/01/02
(0)
bring the wrath of . . . . Hold the phone on that one
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/25/02
(0)
ENOUGH! Libya will not support any side of the GA3.
-
Stephen Roberts/Libyan Socialist Jaramariha
3/25/02
(0)
brief statement on Egyptian position
-
Andy Palmer/Egypt
3/24/02
(0)
Setting the record straight
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/24/02
(0)
Compromise
-
Tom Melville/Peru
3/23/02
(1)
Finally!
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
3/23/02
(1)
A word of caution
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/23/02
(0)
Reply to Mr. Eistep
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
3/23/02
(1)
Re: Reply to Mr. Eistep
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/23/02
(1)
Yes, "NEW" link is indeed good - and general remarks to Mr. Iosad
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/23/02
(1)
Proposal
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
3/25/02
(0)
If I may interject
-
Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China
3/24/02
(1)
respectfully disagree and your newspaper editorial
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/24/02
(0)
Re: Reply to Mr. Eistep
-
Joaquin Patron / Liechtenstein
3/23/02
(1)
Here is the link again
-
Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China
3/24/02
(1)
Re: Here is the link again
-
Joaquin¨Patron / Liexchtenstein
3/26/02
(0)
Re: Reply to Mr. Eistep
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
3/23/02
(1)
There will be no reply
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/23/02
(1)
Dismay (n/t)
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
3/25/02
(0)
Withdrawal of Cape Verde from GA3
-
President of the General Assembly
3/23/02
(0)
My E-Mail Server is Down. Please re-direct all e-mail to my new e-mail.
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/23/02
(1)
Re: My E-Mail Server is Down. Please re-direct all e-mail to my new e-mail.
-
UNOL staff
3/23/02
(1)
Re: My E-Mail Server is Down. Please re-direct all e-mail to my new e-mail.
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/24/02
(0)
observers invited to the United Nations
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/22/02
(1)
Glad you're back
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
3/23/02
(1)
Re: Glad you're back
-
Joaquin Patron / Liechtenstein
3/23/02
(1)
Re: Glad you're back
-
Tom Melville/Peru
3/23/02
(0)
Opening Statement on GA3 (Against)
-
Yancey Westerfield/Lesotho
3/22/02
(0)
Some other countries which should support GA3
-
Joaquin Patron / Liechtenstein
3/22/02
(1)
Further Information
-
Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China
3/22/02
(1)
Re: Further Information
-
Joaquin Patron / Liechtenstein
3/23/02
(1)
Re: Further Information
-
Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China
3/23/02
(0)
Confusion (apologies) and Other Information
-
Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China
3/22/02
(1)
Re: Confusion (apologies) and Other Information
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/22/02
(0)
Dismay at the attitudes of certain delegations
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/22/02
(1)
Re: Dismay at the attitudes of certain delegations
-
Tom Melville/Peru
3/23/02
(0)
Liechtenstein FOR GA3
-
Joaquin Patron / Liechtenstein
3/21/02
(1)
Thank you
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/22/02
(0)
In agreement + Iceland pledges support
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
3/22/02
(1)
Is Iceland a typo by Ireland?
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/22/02
(1)
No, Iceland isn't a typo by Ireland
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
3/22/02
(1)
Our apologies
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/22/02
(1)
Apology accepted
-
Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland
3/23/02
(0)
Syrian Arab Republic amazed by supporters of GA3
-
Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic
3/22/02
(1)
Re: Syrian Arab Republic amazed by supporters of GA3
-
Tom Melville/Peru
3/23/02
(0)
Re: Syrian Arab Republic amazed by supporters of GA3
-
Joaquin Patron / Liechtenstein
3/22/02
(1)
Some comments
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
3/22/02
(1)
Re: Some comments
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/22/02
(1)
sorry, these remarks were supposed to be addressed to Hungary
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/22/02
(0)
Rebuttal to the the Thai Arguments and some points raised elsewhere
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/21/02
(1)
Response
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/22/02
(0)
More points to add
-
Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary
3/22/02
(1)
Re: More points to add
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/22/02
(0)
A solemn promise (Please Read)
-
Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom
3/21/02
(0)
Fairy Tales!!! Read on
-
Vlad Gil (Russian Federation)
3/21/02
(1)
Rightly so, but even then, I didn't ask for Aesop to represent himself
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/22/02
(0)
Full agreement with Russia, UK and China
-
Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic
3/22/02
(0)
Assuming the Sponsorship of GA-3 and other points to it.
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/21/02
(1)
Ambassador Eistep
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/21/02
(1)
Sorry, accidentally pressed enter, please read this one
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/21/02
(1)
GA3 and Other Issues *Delegates Please Read*
-
President of the General Assembly
3/21/02
(0)
Diplomacy - Negotiation and compromise.
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/21/02
(0)
Opening statement, and Thailand's position
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/21/02
(0)
Russia's 10 points, rebuttals, etc
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/21/02
(1)
My apologies for a harsh and sarcastic reply
-
Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand
3/21/02
(0)
opening statement
-
Zeek Earl / South Africa
3/20/02
(0)
*Urgent Message - All Delegates Please Read!*
-
Secretary-General
3/20/02
(0)
Russia's Top Ten list
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/19/02
(1)
special note -
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/19/02
(0)
Opening Statement on GA3
-
Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China
3/19/02
(0)
Position On GA3
-
Mike Arthus/Costa Rica
3/19/02
(0)
Opening Statement against GA3
-
Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic
3/19/02
(0)
Signature Withdrawals
-
President of the General Assembly
3/19/02
(0)
Opening Statement on GA3
-
Marcel Carrijo/Brazil
3/19/02
(0)
Iraq stands Against GA 3
-
Martin Galanternik/Iraq
3/18/02
(0)
TEN POINTS (Please Read)!!!
-
Vlad Gil (Russian Federation)
3/18/02
(1)
quick correction
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/18/02
(0)
Planting the flag: Both reality and progressivism belong to the supporteres of GA3
-
Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands
3/18/02
(0)
Hello From Costa Rica
-
Michael Arthus/Costa Rica
3/16/02
(1)
Re: Hello From Costa Rica
-
Marcel Carrijo/Brazil
3/18/02
(1)
Re: Hello From Costa Rica
-
Mike Arthus/Costa Rica
3/18/02
(0)
Re: Hello From Costa Rica
-
Tom Melville/Peru
3/17/02
(1)
Re: Hello From Costa Rica
-
Mike Arthus/Costa Rica
3/17/02
(0)
Welcome Back
-
Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico
3/17/02
(1)
Thank You
-
Mike Arthus/Costa Rica
3/17/02
(0)