Debate on GA-4 from 04/15/02-05/05/02

IMPORTANT NOTE -- DO NOT post replies to any messages listed here, they won't show up in the Committee. Any discussion needing to be continued should be re-posted in the Caucus area.

• Congratulations to Switzerland - Kenneth VanDewark / Republic of Ecuador 5/05/02 (0)
• Point of Information - Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary 5/05/02 (1)
  • Re: Point of Information - Secretary-General 5/05/02 (1)
    • Thanks (n/t) - Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary 5/05/02 (0)
• GA4 (Admission of Switzerland to the UN) Secures Passage [47-1-1] - President of the General Assembly 5/05/02 (0)
• FOR - James Maskell/Norway 4/29/02 (0)
• GA4 (Admission of Switzerland to the UN) - VOTE HERE - President of the General Assembly 4/26/02 (1)
  • VOTING CLOSED - President of the General Assembly 5/05/02 (0)
  • FOR - Sumeer Kalyani / India 5/04/02 (0)
  • For - B. Borzone 5/03/02 (1)
    • POINT OF ORDER - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 5/03/02 (1)
      • Ruling - President of the General Assembly 5/04/02 (0)
  • For - Matt Madej/Poland 5/03/02 (0)
  • Against. (Please Disgard my Absent Reply) - Stephen Roberts/Libyan Socialist Jaramariha 5/02/02 (1)
    • Noted (n/t) - President of the General Assembly 5/04/02 (0)
  • FOR - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 5/02/02 (0)
  • Absent - Stephen Roberts/Libyan Socialist Jaramariha 5/02/02 (0)
  • FOR - Outi Lundahl/Mongolia 5/02/02 (0)
  • Observer Present - Ken Arnold / Commonwealth Secretariat 5/01/02 (0)
  • For - Taylor Green/Iceland 5/01/02 (0)
  • For - Nicolae Ivanov/Republic of Kazakhstan 5/01/02 (0)
  • For - Yancey Westerfield/Lesotho 5/01/02 (0)
  • FOR - Tyler Bender/ Austria 5/01/02 (0)
  • For - Alex Teh/ Vietnam 5/01/02 (0)
  • FOR - Ian Sutton/Republic of Korea 4/30/02 (0)
  • For - Dan Frøskeland / Japan 4/30/02 (0)
  • FOR - James Maskell/Norway 4/30/02 (0)
  • Observer Present - Drew Beck/Caribbean Community 4/29/02 (0)
  • FOR - Kenneth VanDewark / Republic of Ecuador 4/29/02 (0)
  • For - Nathan Bishop/ Pakistan 4/29/02 (0)
  • FOR - Fatima DeMesme/ The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia 4/29/02 (0)
  • Observer Present - Martin Köhring / European Union 4/29/02 (0)
  • FOR - Xavier Lopez-Ayala / Lithuania 4/29/02 (0)
  • Observer present - Andy Palmer/League of Arab Staes 4/29/02 (0)
  • FOR - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 4/29/02 (0)
  • Yes - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 4/29/02 (0)
  • For - Kim Constable = Italy 4/29/02 (0)
  • FOR - Craig Countryman/Bangladesh 4/29/02 (0)
  • for - Steven Wagner/Israel 4/28/02 (0)
  • FOR - Aaron Connelly / España 4/28/02 (0)
  • For - Drew Beck/Barbados 4/28/02 (0)
  • FOR - Alison Fenney/ Cape Verde 4/28/02 (0)
  • For - Siir Kilkis/Turkey 4/28/02 (0)
  • For - Ian Kowalski / Mauritius 4/28/02 (0)
  • FOR - Hansel J. Cordeiro/Singapore 4/28/02 (0)
  • For - Erin Alsup / Iran 4/28/02 (0)
  • FOR - Doug McCloud/Belarus 4/28/02 (0)
  • For - Tom Melville/Peru 4/28/02 (0)
  • For - Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand 4/28/02 (0)
  • For - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 4/28/02 (0)
  • FOR - Jai Patel / The Republic of Zimbabwe 4/28/02 (0)
  • For - Robert Lane / Republic of France 4/27/02 (0)
  • abstain - Peter Tasciotti, Vanuatu 4/27/02 (0)
  • For - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 4/27/02 (0)
  • FOR - Bradley Martin/ Federaed States of Micronesia 4/27/02 (0)
  • For - Marcel Carrijo/Brazil 4/27/02 (0)
  • For - Zeek Earl / South Africa 4/27/02 (0)
  • FOR - Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland 4/27/02 (0)
  • For - Shane S Gayle........Federal Republic of Germany 4/27/02 (0)
  • For - Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary 4/27/02 (0)
  • For - Andy Palmer/Egypt 4/27/02 (0)
  • For - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 4/27/02 (0)
  • FOR - Stephanie Tjia/Myanmar 4/27/02 (0)
  • FOR - Mario Tjia/Papua New Guinea 4/27/02 (0)
  • Re: GA4 (Admission of Switzerland to the UN) - VOTE HERE - David Ramli 4/26/02 (0)
  • FOR - Joaquin Patron / Colombia 4/26/02 (0)
  • FOR - Brian Grassie/USA 4/26/02 (0)
  • FOR, or AGAINST, or ABSTAIN - Name / Country 4/26/02 (0)
• Reminder and Motion Accepted - President of the General Assembly 4/25/02 (1)
  • Motion Closed - Passed Without Opposition - President of the General Assembly 4/26/02 (0)
  • Second - Douglas Mains/Brunei Darussalem 4/26/02 (0)
  • Second - David Ramli / Australia 4/26/02 (0)
  • Second - Shane S Gayle.........Federal Republic of Germany 4/26/02 (0)
  • Second - Hansel J. Cordeiro/Singapore 4/26/02 (0)
  • Second - Zeek Earl / South Africa 4/25/02 (0)
  • second - Brian Grassie/USA 4/25/02 (0)
  • Second - Joaquin Patron / Colombia 4/25/02 (0)
  • Second - Andy Palmer/Egypt 4/25/02 (0)
• Motion to close debate - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 4/24/02 (1)
  • Second - Shane S Gayle.....Federal Republic of Germany 4/25/02 (0)
  • Re: Motion to close debate - Alex Teh/ Vietnam 4/25/02 (1)
    • Second (pls ignore other post) - Alex Teh/ Vietnam 4/25/02 (0)
  • Second - David Ramli/Australia 4/25/02 (0)
  • Second - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 4/24/02 (0)
  • Second - Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland 4/24/02 (0)
• Honoured to be here/ Statement of Support - Alex Teh/ Vietnam 4/24/02 (0)
• Honoured to be here/ Statement of Support - Alex Teh/ Vietnam 4/24/02 (0)
• Swis Entry into the UK - Kin Constable - Italy 4/24/02 (1)
  • Apologies - Kim Constable - Italy 4/26/02 (0)
  • Re: Swis Entry into the UK - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 4/24/02 (0)
• E-mail status - Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland 4/23/02 (0)
• fully supports Switzerland's admission to the UN - Mario Tjia/ Papua New Guinea 4/23/02 (0)
• GA4 - Mike Arthus/Costa Rica 4/22/02 (0)
• Opening Statement - Drew Beck/Barbados 4/21/02 (0)
• Point - Shane S Gayle......Federal Republic of Germany 4/21/02 (1)
  • Re: Point - Joaquin Patron / Colombia 4/21/02 (1)
    • A point to be made - Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary 4/22/02 (1)
      • Re: A point to be made - Joaquin Patron / Colombia 4/23/02 (1)
        • Re: A point to be made - Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary 4/23/02 (0)
• Opening Statement - Pavel Iosad / Republic of Hungary 4/21/02 (0)
• Change of email address (permanent) - Syed Munir Alhamid / Thailand 4/21/02 (0)
• Swiss - Caroling Baker/Greece 4/20/02 (0)
• Swiss membership - Andy Palmer/Egypt 4/20/02 (0)
• Opening Statement - GA4 - Doug McCloud/Belarus 4/19/02 (0)
• just one concern - Steven Wagner/Israel 4/19/02 (1)
  • Re: just one concern - James Maskell/Norway 4/20/02 (1)
    • agreed - Steven Wagner/Israel 4/20/02 (0)
• Switzerland's Admission To The U.N - Tom Melville/Peru 4/19/02 (0)
• Statement on Switzerland - Sumeer Kalyani / India 4/19/02 (0)
• Switzerland - Roger Lawrence/Sweden 4/17/02 (0)
• Statement on GA 4 - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 4/17/02 (0)
• Opening Statement on GA4 - James Maskell/Norway 4/17/02 (0)
• Official Statement of GA4 - Bradley Martin/Federated States of Micronesia 4/16/02 (0)
• Official Statement on GA4 - Jai Patel - The Republic of Zimbabwe 4/15/02 (0)
• Opening Statement on GA4 - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 4/15/02 (0)
• Support GA4 - Zeek Earl / South Africa 4/15/02 (0)
• Mission of Germany: Official Opening Statement on GA4 - Shane S Gayle....Federal Republic of Germany 4/15/02 (0)
• A minor Point of Order - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 4/15/02 (1)
  • Ruling - President of the General Assembly 4/15/02 (0)
  • Re: A minor Point of Order - Shane S Gayle....Germany 4/15/02 (0)
• Full Support for GA4 - David Ramli/Australia 4/15/02 (0)
• Debate Open - GA4 (Admission of Switzerland to the UN) - President of the General Assembly 4/15/02 (0)
• Full Support for GA4 - Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland 4/14/02 (0)
• A Reply To Mr. Eistep. - Stephen Roberts/Libyan Socialist Jaramariha 4/14/02 (1)
  • Honorable Libyan Ambassador - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 4/15/02 (0)
  • Re: A Reply To Mr Roberts - Tom Melville/Peru 4/15/02 (0)
• Full Support for GA4 - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 4/13/02 (1)
  • Re: Full Support for GA4 - Joaquin Patron / Colombia 4/14/02 (0)
  • Re: Full Support for GA4 - B.Martin/Federated States of Micronesia 4/14/02 (0)
  • Re: GA4 - Yancey Westerfield/Lesotho 4/13/02 (1)
    • Re: GA4 - James Maskell/Norway 4/15/02 (0)
  • Re: Full Support for GA4 - Shane S Gayle.......Federal Republic of Germany 4/13/02 (0)
• Opinion on GA4. - Stephen Roberts/Libyan Socialist Jaramariha 4/13/02 (1)
  • Re: Opinion on GA4. - Doug McCloud/Belarus 4/19/02 (0)
  • Re: Opinion on GA4. - Brian Grassie/USA 4/14/02 (0)
  • Re: Opinion on GA4. - Brian Eistep/Marshall Islands 4/13/02 (0)
  • Re: Opinion on GA4. - Joaquin Patron / Colombia 4/13/02 (0)
• GA4 - David Ramli/Australia 4/13/02 (0)