Debate on GA-8 from 11/23/02-12/17/02

IMPORTANT NOTE -- DO NOT post replies to any messages listed here, they won't show up in the Committee. Any discussion needing to be continued should be re-posted in the Caucus area.

• Apologies for missing vote & statement - Sumeer Kalyani / India 12/22/02 (0)
• Final Remarks - Michael Pangborn / Saudi Arabia 12/19/02 (0)
• Sponsor's Closing Statement - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/18/02 (0)
• Closing Statement - Michael Hughes/Commonwealth of Canada 12/17/02 (1)
  • Re: Closing Statement - Brian Grassie/United States of America 12/18/02 (1)
    • Re: Closing Statement - Michael Hughes/Commonwealth of Canada 12/19/02 (1)
      • Re: Closing Statement - Brian Grassie/United States of America 12/22/02 (1)
        • Re: Closing Statement - Michael Hughes/Commonwealth of Canada 12/23/02 (1)
          • Re: Closing Statement - Brian Grassie/United States of America 12/23/02 (0)
      • Re: Closing Statement - Tom Reevell/Vietnam 12/21/02 (0)
      • Re: Closing Statement - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 12/20/02 (0)
  • Another minor correction - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 12/18/02 (0)
  • A minor point - Robert Lane / Republic of France, EU 12/17/02 (1)
    • My point exactly - Michael Hughes/Commonwealth of Canada 12/18/02 (0)
• Closing Statement on GA8 - Pavel Iosad / Russian Federation 12/17/02 (0)
• GA8 (Nuclear Arms) Secures Passage [22-6-10] - President of the General Assembly 12/17/02 (0)
• For - Glenn Griffiths/Indonesia 12/11/02 (1)
  • Point of Order - Tom Reevell/Vietnam 12/11/02 (0)
• FOR - Tom Reevell/Vietnam 12/09/02 (1)
  • Point of Order - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/09/02 (1)
    • Re: Point of Order - Tom Reevell/Vietnam 12/09/02 (1)
      • Re: Point of Order - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 12/10/02 (0)
• Statement on Nuclear Arms (Important: Please Read!) - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 12/08/02 (1)
  • Russia's position - Pavel Iosad / Russian Federation 12/09/02 (0)
  • Congratulations on Statement / Other Info - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/08/02 (1)
    • Re: Congratulations on Statement / Other Info - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 12/10/02 (1)
      • Response - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/10/02 (1)
        • Of course it will! - Pavel Iosad / Russian Federation 12/11/02 (0)
• GA8 (Nuclear Arms) - VOTE HERE - President of the General Assembly 12/08/02 (1)
  • VOTING CLOSED - President of the General Assembly 12/16/02 (0)
  • Against n/t - Tom Melville/Peru 12/15/02 (0)
  • ABSTAIN - Joaquin Patron / Mexico 12/15/02 (0)
  • for - Ian Sutton/ROK 12/15/02 (0)
  • Against - Trevor-Sierra Leone 12/14/02 (0)
  • For - Glenn Griffiths/Indonesia 12/14/02 (0)
  • For - Peter Van de Reep / Swiss Confederation 12/14/02 (0)
  • Abstain (With Rights) - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 12/14/02 (0)
  • Abstain - Yancey Westerfield/Lesotho 12/13/02 (0)
  • For - ian Kowalski / Mauritius 12/13/02 (0)
  • Against (With Statement) - Robert Lane / Republic of France, EU 12/13/02 (0)
  • ABSTAIN (with statement) - Michael Pangborn / Saudi Arabia 12/12/02 (0)
  • Against, with rights - Pavel Iosad / Russian Federation 12/12/02 (0)
  • No with RIghts - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 12/12/02 (0)
  • FOR - Martin Kohring / Kingdom of Denmark 12/12/02 (0)
  • Observer Present - Drew Beck/Caribbean Community 12/11/02 (0)
  • Abstain (+Statement) - Drew Beck/Barbados 12/11/02 (0)
  • For (with comments) - Jeremy Aldrich/Côte d'Ivoire 12/11/02 (0)
  • ABSTAIN (Plus Statement) - Peter Bancroft/Democratic Republic of North Korea 12/11/02 (0)
  • Abstain - La Francophonie 12/11/02 (1)
    • Reminder + Ruling - President of the General Assembly 12/12/02 (1)
      • observer present - Sarah/La Francophonie 12/13/02 (0)
  • ABSTAIN (w/ statement) - Antonio Graça / Portugal 12/11/02 (0)
  • For - Zeek Earl / South Africa 12/10/02 (0)
  • ABSTAIN - Marcel Carrijo/Brazil 12/10/02 (0)
  • For - Liam O'Brien/Arab Republic of Egypt 12/10/02 (0)
  • for - Hannah Lawson/Mali 12/10/02 (0)
  • for - Amber Davis/ Malawi 12/10/02 (0)
  • FOR - Nicole Hughes/Benin 12/10/02 (0)
  • Abstain - David Ramli / Commonwelath of Australia 12/10/02 (0)
  • For (short statement) - Matt Madej/Poland 12/10/02 (0)
  • AGAINST, w. explanation - Brian Grassie/United States of America 12/09/02 (0)
  • Observer Present - Martin Kohring / European Union 12/09/02 (0)
  • FOR - Stephanie Monroe/ Chad 12/09/02 (0)
  • FOR - Allison Clark/Bhutan 12/09/02 (0)
  • FOR - Seth Roller/Rwanda 12/09/02 (0)
  • For + statement + apology for voting procedure violation - Michael Hughes/Canada 12/09/02 (0)
  • Re: GA8 (Nuclear Arms) - VOTE HERE - Michael Hughes/Canada 12/09/02 (0)
  • FOR - David Taylor/ Republic of Austria 12/09/02 (0)
  • Observer Present - Christine Lambino/Palestine 12/08/02 (0)
  • Observer Present - Glen Krueger / League of Arab States 12/08/02 (0)
  • Abstain (with statement) - Glen Krueger / Republic of Lebanon 12/08/02 (0)
  • FOR, with statement - Betsy Mann/ The Solomon Islands 12/08/02 (0)
  • FOR - Kaj Alftan / Monaco 12/08/02 (0)
  • FOR (with statement) - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/08/02 (0)
  • FOR, or AGAINST, or ABSTAIN (with statement) - Name / Country 12/08/02 (1)
    • FOR - Tom Reevell/Vietnam 12/09/02 (0)
    • FOR - Emily Schmiesing / Mozambique 12/09/02 (0)
• Withdrawal of Signature - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 12/08/02 (1)
  • Response - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/08/02 (0)
• GA8 Vote - Tom Reevell/Viet Nam 12/08/02 (1)
  • Thanks / Point of Order - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/08/02 (0)
• Update - Betsy Mann/ The Solomon Islands 12/07/02 (1)
  • Explanation + List of Updates - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/08/02 (1)
    • Thank you - Betsy Mann/ The Solomon Islands 12/08/02 (0)
• GA8 Updated - President of the General Assembly 12/07/02 (0)
• Updated GA8 -- No Tabling - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/07/02 (0)
• Motion Notification - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/07/02 (0)
• GA8 - Zeek Earl / South Africa 12/05/02 (0)
• Probable Tabling of GA8 - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/05/02 (0)
• Palestine's Comments on GA-8 - Christine Lambino/Palestine 12/04/02 (0)
• Position on GA-8 - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 12/04/02 (1)
  • Response (proper formatting) - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/05/02 (0)
  • Response - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/05/02 (0)
• Austria GA8 update. - David Taylor/ Austria 12/04/02 (0)
• Costa Rican Position on GA8 - Mike Arthus/Costa Rica 12/03/02 (0)
• Bid to sponsor - Pavel Iosad / Russian Federation 12/03/02 (1)
  • Response from Sponsor - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/03/02 (1)
    • Re: Response from Sponsor - David Taylor/ Austria 12/04/02 (0)
    • Re: - Betsy Mann/ The Solomon Islands 12/03/02 (0)
• Changing Secretary General Instructions - Michael Pangborn / Central African Republic 12/02/02 (1)
  • Re: Changing Secretary General Instructions - Emily Schmiesing / Mozambique 12/03/02 (0)
  • Re: Changing Secretary General Instructions - David Taylor/ Austria 12/02/02 (0)
• Austria's Position - David Taylor/Austria 12/02/02 (0)
• Statement - Sumeer Kalyani / India 12/01/02 (1)
  • New Delegate - Kelli Gates 12/02/02 (0)
  • Re: Statement - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/01/02 (1)
    • Re: Statement - Sumeer Kalyani / India 12/01/02 (1)
      • Kashmir Clause - Ian Beacock / Germany 12/01/02 (1)
        • Re: Kashmir Clause - Sumeer Kalyani / India 12/02/02 (0)
• The Solomon Islands Postion - Betsy Mann/ The Solomon Islands 11/30/02 (1)
  • The Monegasque Position - Kaj Alftan / Monaco 12/07/02 (0)
  • Response - Michael Pangborn / Central African Republic 12/01/02 (1)
    • Re: Response - Emily Schmiesing / Mozambique 12/02/02 (0)
• Failure to address the basic problem - Antonio Graça / Portugal 11/28/02 (1)
  • Response to All - Ian Beacock / Germany 11/28/02 (1)
    • Re: Response to All - Antonio Graça/Portugal 11/29/02 (1)
      • Questions - Ian Beacock / Germany 11/29/02 (1)
        • Re: Questions - Antonio Graça / Portugal 12/04/02 (0)
• Opening Statement on GA8 - Pavel Iosad / Russian Federation 11/28/02 (1)
  • Agreement on Certain Aspects - Ian Beacock / Germany 11/28/02 (0)
• Canada's position - Michael Hughes/Canada 11/27/02 (0)
• Opening Statement on GA8 - Yancey Westerfield/Lesotho 11/26/02 (0)
• Concurrance with CAR - Michael Hughes/Sudan 11/26/02 (1)
  • Response to Amendments - Michael Pangborn / Central African Republic 11/28/02 (0)
• Suggestion - Michael Pangborn / Central African Republic 11/24/02 (1)
  • Suggestion Recognized, However... - Ian Beacock / Germany 11/25/02 (1)
    • No Promises - Michael Pangborn / Central African Republic 11/25/02 (1)
      • Response (to CAR and Sudan) - Ian Beacock / Germany 11/26/02 (0)
• Remarks on GA8 - Michael Hughes/Sudan 11/23/02 (1)
  • Answer from the Sponsor - Ian Beacock / Germany 11/24/02 (0)
• Sponsor's Statement on GA8 - Ian Beacock / Germany 11/23/02 (0)
• New Topic (GA8 - Nuclear Arms) + IMPORTANT NOTES - President of the General Assembly 11/23/02 (0)