Debate on SC-1 and SC-2 from 1/02/02-3/17/02

IMPORTANT NOTE -- DO NOT post replies to any messages listed here, they won't show up in the Committee. Any discussion needing to be continued should be re-posted in the Caucus area.

• SC2 (Admission of Switzerland) PASSES 11-0-1 - Vice-President of the Security Council 3/17/02 (0)
• Motion to Trasmit the following resolution and recommendation to the General Assembly - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/15/02 (1)
  • Apologies to France - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/15/02 (1)
    • No Problem, All is Forgiven - Robert Lane / Republic of France 3/17/02 (0)
• VOTE HERE - Admission of Switzerland (SC2) (Quorum Vote) - Vice-President of the Security Council 3/13/02 (1)
  • VOTING CLOSED - Vice-President of the Security Council 3/17/02 (0)
  • For - Ian Kowalski / Mauritius 3/15/02 (0)
  • Re: VOTE HERE - Admission of Switzerland (SC2) (Quorum Vote) - Jonathon Potter / Guinea 3/15/02 (1)
    • Re: VOTE HERE - Admission of Switzerland (SC2) (Quorum Vote) - Augustine Goh/ Federal Republic of Yugoslavia 3/17/02 (1)
      • POINT OF ORDER - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/17/02 (1)
        • Point of Order Noted - Vice-President of the Security Council 3/17/02 (0)
  • For & Statement - Brian Grassie/USA 3/14/02 (0)
  • FOR - Hansel Cordeiro/Singapore 3/14/02 (0)
  • For - Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland 3/14/02 (0)
  • For - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 3/14/02 (0)
  • For (n/t) - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 3/14/02 (0)
  • Abstain (Comment included) - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 3/13/02 (1)
    • Re: Abstain (Comment included) - Hansel Cordeiro/Singapore 3/14/02 (0)
  • For (n/t) - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 3/13/02 (0)
  • For - Robert Lane / Republic of France 3/13/02 (0)
  • Yes - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 3/13/02 (0)
  • Yes - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/13/02 (0)
• Motion to initiate voting procedures on Swiss Admission - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 3/12/02 (1)
  • As long the Russian Proposed Amendments are not Submitted, Seconded - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/12/02 (1)
    • Motion Noted (see note) - Vice-President of the Security Council 3/13/02 (0)
• Admission of Switzerland (Resolution & Russia's Objection) - Hansel Cordeiro/Singapore 3/12/02 (0)
• Opening statement on the Topic - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/11/02 (1)
  • Congratulations to British ambassador - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 3/12/02 (0)
• Draft Resolution on Switzerland's Admission to the United Nations - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/11/02 (1)
  • Proposed Amendments - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 3/11/02 (1)
    • Objection to the proposed amendments and a bit of a history lesson - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/12/02 (0)
    • Answer to your question - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 3/12/02 (0)
    • Profound Opposition to the Proposed Amendments - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 3/12/02 (0)
• Objections to the Admission - Hansel Cordeiro/Singapore 3/11/02 (1)
  • Re: Objections to the Admission - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/12/02 (0)
  • Objection to Swiss Membership - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 3/11/02 (0)
• Agenda Set - Vice-President of the Security Council 3/11/02 (0)
• Answers - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 3/07/02 (1)
  • Re: Answers - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/07/02 (1)
    • Re: Answers - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 3/07/02 (1)
      • Re: Answers - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 3/11/02 (0)
      • Re: Answers - Brian Grassie/USA 3/10/02 (0)
      • Fair enough - Rafael antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/07/02 (0)
• Motion to set the Agenda - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 3/05/02 (1)
  • Objection (Better Wait until the Arab League Summit) - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 3/07/02 (0)
  • Re: Motion to set the Agenda - Brian Grassie/USA 3/07/02 (0)
  • Second (w/ note) - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 3/07/02 (0)
  • Second - Robert Lane / Republic of France 3/06/02 (0)
• Farewell and Best of Luck to SC Next President - Security Council Chair 3/01/02 (1)
  • Re: Farewell and Best of Luck to SC Next President - James M/ SecurityCouncil President 3/12/02 (0)
• Sincere Apologies - Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland 2/22/02 (0)
• Closing Statement - Thanks and Appreciation - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 2/21/02 (0)
• SC1 (Situation in Kashmir) PASSES 9-0-1 - Security Council Chair 2/18/02 (0)
• SC1 (Situation in Kashmir) Updated w/ Amendments - Security Council Chair 2/13/02 (0)
• VOTE HERE - Situation in Kashmir (SC1) - Security Council Chair 2/11/02 (1)
  • VOTING CLOSED - Security Council Chair 2/18/02 (0)
  • For - Ian Kowalski / Mauritius 2/17/02 (0)
  • Abstain - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 2/15/02 (0)
  • FOR - Albert Arey/Republic of Colombia 2/14/02 (0)
  • FOR - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 2/14/02 (0)
  • Yes - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 2/13/02 (0)
  • For - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 2/13/02 (0)
  • For - Robert Lane / Republic of France 2/13/02 (0)
  • For - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 2/13/02 (0)
  • Re: VOTE HERE - Situation in Kashmir (SC1) - James Maskell 2/13/02 (1)
    • For - James Maskell/Norway 2/17/02 (0)
  • For (n/t) - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 2/12/02 (0)
• some upgrades ... - UNOL Staff 2/07/02 (0)
• Concern about Russian Position - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 2/06/02 (1)
  • Russia's response - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 2/06/02 (0)
• Support - Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland 2/06/02 (0)
• support for resolution - Brian/USA 2/06/02 (0)
• Opening Statement - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 2/04/02 (0)
• Motion to end debate - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 2/04/02 (1)
  • Motion Approved - Security Council Chair 2/11/02 (0)
  • Point of Order - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 2/04/02 (1)
    • Point of Order Noted - Security Council Chair 2/11/02 (0)
    • Confusion - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 2/04/02 (1)
      • Re: Confusion - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 2/06/02 (1)
        • Re: Confusion - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 2/09/02 (1)
          • Re: Confusion - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 2/09/02 (1)
            • Re: Confusion - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 2/09/02 (1)
              • Re: Confusion - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 2/10/02 (0)
• Regarding the statements of India and Pakistan - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 1/29/02 (0)
• Reaction to the Intervetions of India and Pakistan - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 1/28/02 (0)
• Statement - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 1/27/02 (0)
• Statements from India and Pakistan - James Maskell/ Norway 1/27/02 (0)
• Statements From India and Pakistan - Security Council Chair 1/24/02 (0)
• Where is the final copy??? - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/21/02 (1)
  • Thank You - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/22/02 (0)
  • Re: Where is the final copy??? - President of the Security Council 1/21/02 (0)
• Motion to end debate - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/21/02 (1)
  • Please read!!! - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/22/02 (0)
  • Opposed - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 1/21/02 (1)
    • Re: Opposed - James Maskell 1/27/02 (0)
  • Re: Motion to end debate - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/21/02 (0)
  • Re: Motion to end debate - Ian Kowalski / Security Council President 1/21/02 (0)
• Recommendations on Inviting the Indian and Pakistani delegations to the Join the Council under Rule 37 - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 1/14/02 (1)
  • Re: Recommendations on Inviting the Indian and Pakistani delegations to the Join the Council under Rule 37 - Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland 1/15/02 (0)
  • Re: Recommendations on Inviting the Indian and Pakistani delegations to the Join the Council under Rule 37 - Jonathon Potter / Republic of Guinea 1/14/02 (0)
• Motion to Invite the delegations of India and Pakistan under Rule 37 of the Provisional Rules of the Security Council - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 1/13/02 (1)
  • Motion Noted - Passes unless there are no objections - Vice-President of the Security Council 1/13/02 (0)
  • Second - Tim Jarman / Republic of Ireland 1/13/02 (0)
  • Second - Robert Lane / Republic of France 1/13/02 (0)
  • Second - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 1/13/02 (0)
  • Second - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/13/02 (0)
• Motion to Extend Debate - Albert Arey/Republic of Colombia 1/13/02 (1)
  • Motion Approved - Vice-President of the Security Council 1/13/02 (0)
  • Second - Robert Lane / Republic of France 1/13/02 (0)
  • Second - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 1/13/02 (0)
  • Re: Motion to Extend Debate - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/13/02 (0)
  • Second - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 1/13/02 (0)
• Point of Parliamentary Inquiry - Albert Arey/Republic of Colombia 1/12/02 (1)
  • Re: Point of Parliamentary Inquiry - Hansel J. Cordeiro/Singapore 1/12/02 (1)
    • Thank you - Albert Arey/Republic of Colombia 1/13/02 (0)
• New Delegation - Tim Jarman / Ireland 1/11/02 (0)
• Greetings - Jonathon Potter / Republic of Guinea 1/10/02 (1)
  • My Regards - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 1/10/02 (0)
• New Delegation - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/08/02 (1)
  • Re: New Delegation - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/09/02 (0)
  • Welcome to the Russian Federation - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 1/09/02 (0)
  • Welcome! - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 1/09/02 (0)
• Updated Situation in Kashmir Resolution sponsored by the People's Republic of China - Debate should continue below this post - Vice-President of the Security Council 1/08/02 (1)
  • Another possible solution & Opinion on Resolution - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/09/02 (1)
    • Answers and Policy Statement - Vlad Gil (Russian Federation) 1/12/02 (0)
    • Thoughts on Resolution - Hansel J. Cordeiro/Singapore 1/11/02 (0)
    • Preliminary Thoughts - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 1/10/02 (0)
    • Re: Another possible solution & Opinion on Resolution - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 1/10/02 (1)
      • Re: Another possible solution & Opinion on Resolution - Rafae;Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 1/10/02 (1)
        • Re: Another possible solution & Opinion on Resolution - Brian Grassie/USA 1/17/02 (0)
  • General support draft resolution, a couple of amendments and, a point of fact on peacekeeping operations in Kashmir - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kindgom 1/09/02 (0)
• Opening Statement - Ian Kowalski / Mauritius 1/07/02 (0)
• Announcing the President of the Security Council & Note on Resolution - Vice-President of the Security Council 1/05/02 (0)
• Motion to invite India and Pakistan to UNOL SC caucus - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 1/04/02 (1)
  • Objection (explanation -- please read) - Albert Arey/Republic of Colombia 1/05/02 (1)
    • Noted - Vice-President of the Security Council 1/05/02 (0)
• Debate on Situation in Kashmir Resolution sponsored by the People's Republic of China - Vice-President of the Security Council 1/04/02 (1)
  • Clause 5 - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 1/08/02 (1)
    • Re: Clause 5 - Hansel J. Cordeiro/Singapore 1/08/02 (0)
    • Re: Clause 5 - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 1/08/02 (1)
      • Peacekeeping Operations in the India Pakistan Border - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 1/09/02 (1)
        • Thankyou but... - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 1/10/02 (0)
  • deep concerns - Brian Grassie/USA 1/05/02 (0)
  • Amendments & Invitations - Hansel Cordeiro/Singapore 1/04/02 (1)
    • Response to Amendments - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 1/04/02 (1)
      • Re: Response to Amendments - Hansel Cordeiro/Singapore 1/06/02 (0)
      • Remarks - Albert Arey/Republic of Colombia 1/05/02 (1)
        • Clarity is perhaps needed - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 1/06/02 (1)
          • Re: Clarity is perhaps needed - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 1/08/02 (1)
            • Acceptable Alternative - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 1/08/02 (1)
              • Re: Acceptable Alternative - Albert Arey/Republic of Colombia 1/08/02 (1)
                • British stab at the laguage on the India-Pakistan hostilities Clause - Rafael Antonio Cabrero/United Kingdom 1/09/02 (1)
                  • Much Thanks - Albert Arey/Republic of Colombia 1/09/02 (1)
                    • Re: Much Thanks - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 1/10/02 (0)
      • Re: Response to Amendments - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 1/04/02 (1)
        • Re: Response to Amendments - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 1/04/02 (0)
    • Re: Amendments & Invitations - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 1/04/02 (0)
  • Re: Debate on Situation in Kashmir Resolution sponsored by the People's Republic of China - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 1/04/02 (0)
• Change of Agenda & Important Message - President of the Security Council 1/03/02 (0)
• India/Pakistan - Brian Grassie/USA 1/02/02 (1)
  • Really an important matter to debate - Paulo Levandovski / Syrian Arab Republic 1/03/02 (0)
  • Agreement and Welcome to New Delegates - Stephen Tapril / People's Republic of China 1/03/02 (0)
  • Concurrence - Jacob Stanovich / Bulgaria 1/02/02 (0)
  • Full Agreement - Ken Arnold / Federal Republic of Mexico 1/02/02 (0)